DNA Evidence and Your Right to Confront the Analyst Who Tested It
When the government uses DNA evidence against someone, who has to come to court to defend that testing? A 2026 Appeals Court decision, Commonwealth v. Pinney (decided September 2, 2026), is a strong example of a defendant's right to confront the witnesses against him — and what happens when that right is violated.
What happened
The defendant was tried for a death the Commonwealth described as a strangulation. A central part of the case was DNA evidence, including the defendant's DNA on the victim's body and a mixed profile on a cloth belt described as a possible ligature.
But the analyst who actually did that testing, Snyder, had left the lab and did not testify. Instead, two substitute analysts took the stand and told the jury about her results. The Commonwealth never showed that the original analyst was unavailable.
What the court decided
The Appeals Court reversed the conviction and ordered a new trial.
Under the Constitution's Confrontation Clause — and recent decisions including the U.S. Supreme Court's Smith v. Arizona (2024) and Massachusetts's Commonwealth v. Gordon (2025) — the prosecution generally cannot have one analyst testify to the testing another analyst performed, unless that original analyst is genuinely unavailable and the defense had a chance to cross-examine. The Commonwealth even conceded the error.
The court held the mistake was not harmless. The DNA was the main thing corroborating a cooperating witness who had testified under immunity, had a history with the victim, and gave shifting accounts — and the prosecutor emphasized the DNA in opening and closing. The court could not be sure the substitute-analyst testimony did not affect the verdict.
Why this matters
Forensic evidence can look unbeatable to a jury, but it still has to be presented the right way:
- The person who actually did the testing generally has to be available for cross-examination.
- If the prosecution uses a stand-in analyst without showing the original is unavailable, that can violate your confrontation rights.
- A preserved objection gives you the strongest standard of review on appeal.
How evidence is introduced — and whether your attorney objects at the right moments — can change the result of a case. These are the kinds of issues that come up throughout criminal cases and appeals.
If DNA or other forensic evidence is part of your case, contact the office to discuss it.
Source: Commonwealth v. Pinney, official opinion (mass.gov)
This article is general information about a Massachusetts court decision, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different.
Topics: Criminal Defense, Case Law Updates
